Property Description

Own a true piece of Sutton’s past in the Village of West Sutton. Listed on the Historic Register yet free from restriction, this remarkable antique was once home to the Samuel Waters family, later a tavern & cider mill, & the residence of early suffragette Lucy Phelps—whose signature remains on the upstairs walls alongside original wide boards, horsehair plaster, & 18th-century hand-drawn designs. Timeless character & ornate architectural details shine throughout, w/ beamed ceilings, HW floors in select rooms, multiple fireplaces, & preserved period craftsmanship that simply can’t be replicated. The main home offers 2 levels plus a walk-up attic, 4 fireplaces, living & dining rooms, custom built kitchen by David T Smith, office, & 3 bedrooms. Two attached units—each w/ separate living space, kitchens, baths, & fireplaces—provide strong rental income potential for investors or owner occupants! Unpaved driveway parking and easy access to Rte 146, 395 & 1-90 complete this rare opportunity